Homemade Puppies Dog Toy Guide: Safe, Smart Choices for Growing Puppies

Val Nocito • December 10, 2021

Play Is Learning

young puppy playing with safe developmentally appropriate toys in a family living room

Playtime is more than just fun for puppies — it’s a key part of their development. The right toys teach problem-solving, provide healthy chewing outlets, build confidence, and strengthen the bond between puppy and family.

At Homemade Puppies, we encourage families to think of toys as tools for growth. Choosing wisely supports your puppy’s physical, emotional, and behavioral health from the very start.


Why Toy Choice Matters

Puppies experience the world through their mouths. Chewing, tugging, carrying, and exploring are natural ways they learn boundaries and relieve stress. Safe, structured play guides these instincts in healthy directions.

Good toy selection also prevents frustration and destructive habits. With the right options, your puppy learns:

  • What’s acceptable to chew
  • When to play calmly
  • How to play independently
  • How to focus during enrichment



Types of Toys Every Puppy Needs

1. Teething Toys

Soft rubber or flexible nylon toys give puppies an appropriate outlet for sore gums. Look for toys firm enough to chew but gentle on developing teeth


puppy chewing a soft rubber teething toy designed for sore puppy gums

2. Comfort Toys

Plush toys with minimal or no stuffing can provide warmth and familiarity, especially during crate training or rest times. Always supervise to ensure no small pieces become loose.

3. Interactive Toys

Toys that roll, rattle, or bounce unpredictably keep play sessions engaging and build coordination, focus, and curiosity.

4. Tug and Bond Toys

Soft tug toys create connection through interactive play. Avoid intense tugging until adult teeth are fully developed.

5. Solo Play Toys

Hard rubber toys like the West Paw Toppl can be filled with treats or frozen snacks for calming, independent play. These toys support patience and mental focus.

puppy resting in crate with safe plush comfort toy for crate training

Safety and Supervision

Always choose toys sized appropriately for your puppy’s breed and age.

  • Avoid toys with small, detachable parts
  • Avoid toys that splinter or shred
  • Rotate toys weekly to maintain interest
  • Inspect regularly for signs of wear
  • Supervise until your puppy consistently plays safely

A few well-chosen toys are better than a basket full of overstimulating or unsafe ones. Quality builds confidence; quantity does not.
American Kennel Club’s safety recommendations for dog toys


Trainer Approved Toy Picks

flat lay of recommended safe puppy toys including Toppl, tug toy, and dental chew

Breeders and trainers in our network consistently recommend:

  • West Paw Toppl
  • Virbac Dental Chews
  • Lick Mats
  • Chuckit! Indoor Ball
  • Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel

Families can find these through trusted pet retailers or their breeder’s preferred suppliers.


From our Trainers

Toys aren’t simply entertainment — they teach puppies how to live calmly alongside people. Each toy is a chance to practice:

  • Focus
  • Patience
  • Gentle play
  • Independence

Families wanting deeper guidance can explore programs through Neshaminy Creek Dog Training, where structured play blends naturally with balanced behavior and communication.


Closing Thought

The best toy is one that builds connection, confidence, and calm. By choosing safe, thoughtful toys and engaging with your puppy daily, you’re not just keeping them occupied — you’re helping them grow into the well-rounded companion they were meant to be.

By Val Nocito December 4, 2025
Discover the most popular family friendly dog breeds in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Delaware, and Maryland. A simple guide for families choosing their next puppy.
home raised puppy in breeder’s home environment
By Val Nocito December 4, 2025
Learn how to choose a responsible dog breeder in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Delaware, or Maryland. A simple guide for families searching for a healthy, home raised puppy.
breeder holding healthy puppy with health testing and paperwork visible
By Val Nocito November 24, 2025
Learn why genetic testing and health clearances are essential for responsible breeding. Understand how these screenings support healthier puppies and confident families.
breeder gently holding a newborn puppy during early developmental period
By Val Nocito November 24, 2025
Discover how Early Neurological Stimulation (ENS) and Early Scent Introduction (ESI) build confident, resilient puppies. Learn why responsible breeders use these science-backed methods.
breeder gently holding newborn puppy highlighting early temperament shaping
By Val Nocito November 24, 2025
Discover how early experiences, breeder-guided exposure, and temperament testing shape confident, well-adjusted puppies. Learn how families find the perfect match.
family with a new puppy at the vet preparing for long term health and protection
By Val Nocito November 24, 2025
Learn why pet insurance is essential for puppy owners. Explore coverage options, breeder-supported programs, and how to protect your dog from unexpected vet costs.
dog using a puzzle toy for mental enrichment at home
By Val Nocito November 24, 2025
Discover why mental enrichment is essential for dogs of all ages. Learn scent work, puzzle games, calming activities, and trainer-approved tools.
newborn puppies in a whelping box showing the first stage of puppy development
By Val Nocito November 23, 2025
Discover the four stages of puppy development and how early exposure, socialization, and responsible breeding shape confident, well-adjusted dogs.
breeder gently handling a young puppy to support early socialization and confidence building
By Val Nocito November 23, 2025
Discover why early socialization shapes your puppy’s confidence and emotional health. Learn how responsible breeders use positive exposure from day one.
More Posts